|
General |
Study Status |
Terminated |
522 Number / Requirement Number |
PS150002 / PSS002 |
Date Original Plan Accepted |
12/21/2016
|
Date Current Plan Accepted |
12/21/2016
|
Study Name |
Sampling and Culturing Study
|
Device Name |
Fujifilm duodenoscopes
|
Root Document Number |
K944759
K944620
K042076
|
General Study Protocol Parameters |
Study Design |
Bench/Lab Study
|
Data Source |
New Data Collection
|
Comparison Group |
No Control
|
Analysis Type |
Descriptive
|
Study Population |
|
Detailed Study Protocol Parameters |
Study Objectives |
This is the pilot phase (phase 1) of the Sampling and Culturing Study for Fujifilm. This is a laboratory study in which clinically used duodenoscopes will be reprocessed, sampled, and cultured for microbial growth. Duodenoscopes are flexible side-viewing gastrointestinal endoscopes used in patients undergoing ERCP procedures to address problems with the bile ducts or pancreatic ducts.
The objectives of this pilot phase are as follows: 1. Identify clinical sites to collect duodenoscope samples and identify laboratories for culturing those samples. 2. Train staff on sampling and culturing protocols. 3. Pilot the sampling and culturing protocols to identify errors and inefficiencies in the pilot protocols which will allow for streamlining of the sampling and culturing protocols during the pivotal phase (phase 2) of the study.
|
Study Population |
The study population consists of Fujifilm model ED-530XT duodenoscopes that have been used in ERCP procedures and reprocessed by trained healthcare facility staff in accordance with the duodenoscope reprocessing manual. Duodenoscopes will be subjected to sampling following completion of the cleaning and manual disinfection or disinfection using any of the following automated endoscope reprocessors (AERs): • ASP EvoTech ECR • Medivators Advantage Plus • Medivators DSD Edge • Steris Corporation System 1E Liquid Chemical Sterilant Processing System
|
Sample Size |
Max # of Pilot Install Samples Min # of Sample Base per Scope Scopes Size . 214 30 3 85
|
Key Study Endpoints |
The primary endpoint of the pilot phase is successful completion of duodenoscope sampling and culturing, where the duodenoscope samples were collected from clinically used duodenoscopes from the identified healthcare facilities. Although the expectation is that none of the duodenoscope samples should be positive for high concern organisms or have > 100 CFU of low/moderate concern organisms, a thorough investigation to identify the root causes of positive samples will be conducted for any positive sample.
|
Interim or Final Data Summary |
Final Safety Findings |
To complete the 522 Sampling and Culturing Study, Fujifilm is required to enroll 10 sites and to collect 727 samples. Fujifilm did not enroll a sufficient number of sites or collect a sufficient number of samples to establish a real-world contamination rate.
In their limited data set, Fujifilm was not able to identify the root causes for microbial contamination. They noted that environmental contamination during handling, storage, and sampling could have contributed to microbial contamination of the duodenoscope. Given that the root cause analysis for contaminated duodenoscopes was unable to definitively identify all root causes and in light of the limited data set, their findings may not be representative of all Fujifilm ED-530XT duodenoscopes.
Although Fujifilm was unable to identify all root causes, Fujifilm identified several general mitigations to potentially improve the safe use of duodenoscopes. In addition to those general mitigations, Fujifilm has conducted a market withdrawal of all ED-530XT with fixed distal end caps. FDA has ordered Fujifilm to conduct a sampling/culturing study on their new duodenoscope model with a disposable endcap.
Mitigations • Market withdrawal of older scope models with fixed components and introduction of newer scope models with disposable end caps • Conduct 522 sampling/culturing study on new scope model • Improve the Reprocessing Instructions for Use • Develop a reprocessing video which will graphically, and with audible text, describe the proper reprocessing process • Improve training for company personnel and end users
|