H6: investigation findings: 3251.Investigation conclusion: 18, 61.H10: it was reported the surgeon drilled into the bone, did not tap, and then inserted the screw.The surgical technique guide recommends using taps during bone preparation to help create threads withing the bone for screw insertion.Review of the device history record indicates the instrument conformed to dimensional specifications at the time of manufacturing and passed inspection requirements with no non-conformities reported.There were no issues during the manufacture of this product that would contribute to this complaint condition.The proximal portion of the screw returned to alphatec spine for evaluation.Visual inspection found the screw fractured occurred proximally through the threads of the shank.During in-house testing by engineering, 3.5 mm screws were torqued to failure in a vise as well as inserted into 40 and 50 pcf bone foam in order to compare to the complaint failure.The average c3-c7 pedicle bone mineral density is 39.3 pcf per "cervical spine bone mineral density as a function of vertebral level and anatomic location" by william anderst et.Al.This was used a baseline for selecting bone foam density.Results: held in vise: 3.5 mm screws were held ~10 mm from the tip and torqued until failure.-inserted in 40 pcf bone foam (average pedicle density): for 3.5 mm screws no failures were recorded using strictly axial torsion.To force a failure lateral bending was applied.One sample yielded but did not fracture.The other fractured at a value 13% lower than the strict axial torsion.-inserted in 50 pcf bone foam (25% more dense than average): 3.5 mm screws failed in 50 pcf during insertion at approximately the same values as the strict vise-held torsion.The root cause is result of the torsional load exceeded the design limitations for the screw / screw shank.A very high insertion torque may have been applied if the patient had uncharacteristically dense bone.
|