It was reported via journal article: "title: randomized multicenter trial comparing glue fixation, self-gripping mesh, and suture fixation of mesh in lichtenstein hernia repair (finnmesh study)" authors: kirsi ronka, md, jaana vironen, md, phd, jyrki kossi, md, phd, tanja hulmi, md, seppo silvasti, md, tapio hakala, md, phd, imre ilves, md, indrek song, md, merja hertsi, md, petri juvonen, md, phd, and hannu paajanen, md, phd.Citation: ann surg 2015;262:714¿720; doi: 10.1097/sla.0000000000001458.This randomized, parallel, prospective, multicenter study aimed to compare the early postoperative outcomes (pain scores, operative time, wound complications) and 1-year results of lichtenstein hernioplasty using 3 different meshes and 3 fixation techniques in day-case surgery setting.Between jan2012 and dec2013, 625 patients with inguinal hernia underwent lichtenstein hernioplasty and were allocated to three groups based on the fixation materials used: optilene glue fixation (n=216; n=198 male and n=18 female; mean age of 59 [14] years), progrip self-fixation (n=202; n=192 male and n=10 female; mean age of 56 [14] years) and ultrapro suture fixation (n=207; n=195 male and n=12 female; mean age of 57 [14] years).In suture fixation group, the mesh used was ultrapro and was fixed using 2-0 prolene sutures.Postoperatively in suture fixation group, 14 patients developed wound hematoma and 8 patients had seroma or infection which were treated by revision/antibiotics.In a 1-year follow-up in suture fixation group, mild bulging of the operating area and visual analog scale =3 (considered as chronic pain) were observed in 1 and 12 patients, respectively.The pain was managed with analgesics.Recurrences observed on a one-year follow-up were rare and were not dependent on the fixation method of the mesh.Several surgeon-dependent factors contribute to the good clinical results of our trial: experienced surgeons, identification and dissection of the nerves whenever possible, a meticulous surgical technique that resulted in few wound hematomas, and only few patients staying in the hospital for more than 24 hours.
|